Multiple User Groups Not Taking Affect

[kam270]

Hi, we are using, Freenas 9.2.1.7 which communicates with LDAP to control file permissions.


We have Windows users in multiple groups. Some belong to Finance as their primary group and Admin as another group they belong to. They can only access files from their Primary group.

We use LDAP Account Manager - 4.4 to control which group the users belong to.

We have also been trying to control access from the command line. We hae tried using this :

setfacl -m group@:rwWxpaRc::allow DIR / Or File Name


The problem is only the primary group is being seen / used. I am trying to determine why only on group is being used.


Can someone please help me diagnose where the problem is.



Thanks for the help,

Dan

 

[dlavigne]

It's quite possible this is a bug. If you create a report at bugs.freenas.org, post the issue number here.

 

[kam270]

It's quite possible this is a bug. If you create a report at bugs.freenas.org, post the issue number here.

I ill do but can we make sure Im setting the ACLs correctly



Here is the set up I am trying to achieve.

We have four users belonging to two groups. The groups are Finanace and Manage. I want people to access the FINANCE folder only if they are a member of Finanace group.

Can FREBSD and Freenas allow the user to belong to two groups?

 

[dlavigne]

Can FREBSD and Freenas allow the user to belong to two groups?

Yes.

 

[kam270]

Yes.

OK we are going to try without using ACLs. See if this works. Ill let you know..

 

[kam270]

Yes.

I removed the ACLs and used the standard Linux permissions wrx . Now the multi groups work.