I don't know how you are using the "Intel RAID Controller Card", but if you are mixing ZFS and RAID, that's a recipe for disaster. We recommend using a HBA flashed to IT mode. IBM M1015's are popular here.
Given that you already have 8x2TB drives and hope to add 8x4TB drives, you need to replace your motherboard first. In fact, even with just the 8x2TB drives, I wouldn't even upgrade to 9.1 yet. Your motherboard only supports a maximum of 8GB of RAM. Look at the stickies in the hardware section for suggestions.